Pit Boss Lexington 500 Review: An Easy Starter Smoker for Your Backyard

As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.

The Pit Boss Lexington 500 is an all-in-one wood pellet cooker designed to deliver authentic wood-fired barbecue, smoking, and searing performance in a compact footprint. Our comprehensive pit boss lexington 500 review reveals that this versatile cooker balances user-friendly electronic controls with heavy-duty construction, making it an outstanding entry-level option for backyard cooks who want rich, hardwood smoke flavor without the frustration of traditional charcoal fire management.

This pellet grill suits small households, townhouse residents with limited outdoor square footage, and beginners stepping into low-and-slow barbecue for the first time. Buyers who regularly host massive gatherings or those who demand an oversized fuel hopper for completely unattended overnight smoking sessions should consider larger alternatives instead.

Pit Boss Lexington 500 at a Glance

Temperature Control and Convection Heating

Managing heat is the most intimidating hurdle for new outdoor cooks, but the digital control system on this cooker eliminates the guesswork. The pit boss 500 pellet grill temperature range spans from 180°F for gentle smoking all the way up to 500°F for roasting, baking, and high-heat cooking. Unlike older entry-level cookers that restrict temperature selections to broad 25-degree jumps, this digital interface dials in heat in precise 5°F increments. This granularity allows you to establish the exact thermal environment required for tender briskets, juicy pork butts, or delicate whole chickens seasoned with a savory blend like pit boss chicken and poultry rub.

Beneath the cooking grates, the cooker relies on an internal combustion fan that drives continuous convection airflow. This fan-forced convection moves warm air and hardwood smoke evenly throughout the chamber, eliminating the harsh hot spots commonly found in budget charcoal or gas grills. By circulating heated air across both tiers of cooking space, food cooks at a uniform pace whether it rests near the center of the main grate or elevated on the secondary tier.

This stable thermal environment is what powers the unit’s marketed 8-in-1 cooking versatility. Within a single barrel design, the pit boss 500 fb2 pellet grill allows you to smoke, bake, braise, roast, grill, barbecue, chargrill, and sear. Beginners can smoke a pork shoulder low and slow in the morning, crank the digital controller up to 375°F in the afternoon to bake cornbread or braise vegetables, and finish dinner without juggling multiple outdoor cooking appliances.

Flame Broiler Lever and Direct Searing

A frequent complaint regarding standard pellet smokers is their inability to create a crisp, caramelized crust on burgers and steaks. Because pellet grills primarily operate like outdoor convection ovens using indirect heat, high-heat searing is often compromised. The Pit Boss Lexington 500 overcomes this hurdle with its integrated flame broiler mechanism, which bridges the gap between gentle smoking and direct-fire grilling.

Operating the system is simple thanks to the external pit boss flame broiler lever. By pulling or pushing the handle on the exterior of the barrel, you slide a slotted heat shield plate directly over the burn pot. When open, the plate exposes your meat directly to live hardwood flames, delivering intense radiant temperatures up to 1,000°F. This allows you to smoke steaks at 225°F until they reach internal doneness, pull the lever, and sear both sides to produce steakhouse-quality grill marks in minutes.

Safety and convenience are significant advantages of this lever setup. On earlier pellet cooker designs, accessing direct flame required you to turn off the grill, remove the grates with heat-resistant gloves, and manually shift a greasy steel plate. The external lever lets you switch between indirect smoking and direct-flame searing in a split second without lifting the lid, losing internal heat, or risking painful burns.

Cooking Capacity and Patio Space

Finding a balance between cooking space and patio footprint is crucial for cooks working with smaller backyard setups. The cooker offers 518 square inches of total cooking area distributed across a two-tier rack configuration. The porcelain-coated steel grates are split between a broad primary grilling rack and a removable upper warming rack. This two-tier format provides enough usable room to smoke two whole pork shoulders or several racks of ribs concurrently, while remaining sized appropriately for quick weeknight family meals.

The unit measures 26.7 inches deep, 47 inches wide, and 47.2 inches high, establishing it as a genuinely compact pellet grill for small patio living, suburban townhomes, and cozy decks. If you find yourself cooking for massive neighborhood tailgates, an expansive model like the pit boss 850 provides extra grate volume, while mobile campers might lean toward ultra-portable options such as the tabletop pit boss 150. For residential cooks who want authentic smoked flavor without surrendering half their outdoor entertaining area, the Lexington 500 hits a convenient middle ground.

Despite its manageable dimensions, the grill includes practical built-in utility. A solid bottom shelf sits firmly between the steel legs, offering a dedicated platform to store spare bags of wood pellets, cleaning brushes, and grill tools off the ground. The porcelain-coated grates are also easy to clean, resisting stubborn grease buildup and reducing the elbow grease needed after an extended cooking session.

Digital Interface and Meat Probe Monitoring

The electronic control panel is designed specifically for ease of use, serving the pit boss lexington 500 for beginners audience exceptionally well. The bright LCD screen provides clear readouts of the current internal grill temperature and real-time food probe readings. Instead of adjusting dampers or vents manually, you power on the unit, dial in your target temperature, and let the motorized auger feed pellets into the burn pot automatically to maintain the set temperature.

Monitoring internal food temperature is critical for tender barbecue and food safety. The digital controller features two dedicated meat probe ports, and Pit Boss includes one meat probe in the box. You simply insert the probe into the center of your meat, plug the cable into the control panel port, and monitor internal doneness directly on the digital display without lifting the grill lid.

Opening the smoker lid releases trapped heat and smoke, causing internal temperatures to plunge and extending cook times. By relying on the digital display to track meat doneness, you preserve the internal convection environment and maintain consistent temperatures throughout the cook. While the controller supports two probes, cooks who want to track two separate cuts simultaneously will need to source a second probe separately.

Hopper Design and Build Quality

Fuel storage on this model is intentionally compact to match the grill’s smaller silhouette. The pit boss lexington 500 hopper capacity is rated at 5 pounds of hardwood pellets. This smaller hopper keeps the overall width of the grill contained, allowing it to fit into tight corners and smaller storage spaces. However, this smaller capacity requires careful attention during long smoking sessions, as low-and-slow cooks running past five or six hours will require manual pellet top-offs to avoid running out of fuel.

In terms of materials, the pit boss lexington 500 specs reflect sturdy alloy steel fabrication. Weighing in at 136.6 pounds, the cooker feels anchored and stable once placed on your patio. The matte black finish resists exterior wear, while the inner steel barrel holds heat reliably during moderate weather conditions. The solid steel legs and bottom storage shelf keep the barrel balanced, preventing wobbling when opening and closing the heavy steel lid.

Pit Boss backs this cooker with a 5-year limited manufacturer warranty, providing long-term peace of mind that stands out in the budget outdoor cooking category. Warranties on entry-level smokers often expire after a single year, making a 5-year coverage term an exceptional indicator of structural durability and component reliability.

Who Should Buy the Pit Boss Lexington 500

Buy It If

• You have a small patio, balcony, or modest backyard space that requires a compact outdoor cooker footprint.
• You want a true set-it-and-cook experience with 5°F increment digital controls and built-in meat probe monitoring.
• You enjoy both low-and-slow smoking and direct flame searing, and want to switch between them quickly using an external lever.
• You value long-term durability backed by a solid 5-year manufacturer warranty.

Skip It If

• You need an unattended overnight smoker and dislike refilling a compact 5-pound pellet hopper.
• You regularly cook large-scale meals for church gatherings, large parties, or catering events that exceed 518 square inches of grate space.
• You require lightweight, portable outdoor equipment designed for frequent single-person transportation.

Final Verdict

If you are deciding whether this cooker meets your backyard needs, the pit boss lexington 500 smoker delivers genuine hardwood flavor, stable temperatures, and flexible cooking methods in a tidy, manageable package. The inclusion of the sliding flame broiler lever sets it apart from traditional entry-level smokers, allowing you to sear thick steaks over a 1,000°F open flame right after smoking them to perfection. The digital controller and included meat probe eliminate common rookie mistakes, guiding beginners straight to tender, mouthwatering barbecue results.

When asking is pit boss lexington 500 worth it, the answer depends entirely on your cooking habits and household size. The smaller 5-pound hopper means you cannot simply walk away for a 12-hour brisket cook without checking your fuel level, and the cooking area is best suited for small to mid-sized family meals. If you want a dependable, well-built smoker that fits neatly onto a smaller patio without sacrificing authentic wood-fired performance, the Lexington 500 is a reliable investment for any budding pitmaster.

FAQ

What is the total cooking area on this pellet grill?

The cooker provides 518 square inches of total cooking space arranged across two tiers of porcelain-coated steel grates.

How high does the temperature reach for searing?

While the standard digital control range tops out at 500°F for indirect cooking, pulling the flame broiler lever opens the heat shield to expose direct wood fire up to 1,000°F.

How much wood pellet fuel can the hopper hold?

The hopper holds up to 5 pounds of hardwood pellets, making it compact and space-efficient for everyday grilling sessions.

Does the grill include meat probes for tracking doneness?

The digital control panel features two integrated probe ports, and one meat probe is included in the package so you can monitor food doneness without lifting the lid.

What kind of warranty does Pit Boss provide for this model?

This pellet grill is supported by a 5-year manufacturer warranty covering components and craftsmanship.